Mockingjay
By: Suzanne Collins
Copyright: 2010
Scholastic Press
3 Bookmarks out of 5
ONCE AGAIN, I WOULD LIKE TO REMIND MY READERS THAT THIS REVIEW MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS TO THE PLOT OF THE BOOK. PLEASE DO NOT READ IF YOU DO NOT WISH TO KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT THE LAST BOOK OF THE HUNGER GAMES TRILOGY.
I am particularly excited about being done this trilogy finally because I don't usually get caught up in pop culture fads. I ignored Twilight for everything that it's worth because it seemed shallow, superficial, and contained a horrible role model for young girls everywhere. I decided to read the Hunger Games because, like any human, I suppose, curiosity got the better of me. After finishing the 3rd book, it seems appropriate that I can review the characters in a holistic sense since the plot has been resolved.
I realize why this book is so popular to teenage girls and even women who have not gotten over the fawning over boys stage of their lives. Katniss is a 17-year-old girl who has two amazing men who have unrequited love for her. The first one is Gale, her friend from childhood whom she realizes that she is madly in love with. The second boy is Peeta, the person who shared her hardships in the 74th Hunger Games and helped keep her alive. Both of these boys continue to stay with her despite the fact that BOTH of them know she is kissing them behind the respective boy's back. And, despite knowing all of this, they do not ONCE fight each other when standing in the same room. Instead, they resolve to help each other. In the real world, I'm convinced that one of the guys would have ended up in prison because the other one was beat to a bloody pulp. In the same regard, I find it highly disgusting that Katniss uses BOTH boys throughout all the books because she can't, or doesn't want to, make a decision about which boy she really wants to be with. All of this boils down to a horrible love story that drags down the entire series. Gale's love is so hard to believe because if he wanted to protect Katniss, he should have offered himself in Peeta's place in the Games. Peeta's love is so hard to buy into because he loves a girl whom he barely spoke to for five years and it only came up as a possible strategy to win the Games.
All that aside, however, Suzanne Collins manages to pull together a great dynamic of messed-up characters. I'm a true and honest sucker for any book/TV/movie which have characters who have been tortured and near death together and then watch them interact. In the cafeteria when Peeta, Gale, Katniss, Johanna, Finnick, and Annie are all sitting around while Johanna makes the off-handed comment of hearing Peeta's tortured screams and Finnick jokes about how he shouldn't have re-started Peeta's heart, I ate it up. This feels like real people who are brought together by circumstances out of their control but they can barely figure out how to function as real humans anymore. Peeta's transformation is the best in the entire trilogy because he is a character that is so innocent throughout all the books. That innocence is stripped away from him and Collins makes the reader believe it.
The plot of the story resolved as well as anyone could possibly hope it to resolve. It gave the reader peace of mind and I was halfway happy with how it ended. Although, in my own opinion, I'm surprised that Collins decides to have Katniss marry anyone in the epilogue. Throughout the entire book she swears to never marry and to never have children and I found the turn around in character a very odd way to end the trilogy for readers. Just like the epilogue in Harry Potter, the epilogue in Mockingjay gives the readers an unnecessary look into the future. My advice to any reader is to stop with the last sentence of the last chapter because it gives a much more dramatic ending rather than the last sentence of the epilogue which seems halfhearted and fizzes out.
I've also decided how I would re-write the trilogy into one book to save time and effort. This is merely opinion and not really based in fact at all. But if you decide to read it, hey, maybe you will think it's good as well. The only book should have been Hunger Games. Gale goes in instead of Peeta. Katniss and Gale win with the same berry trick. They go back to District 12, not having won over the government in any real sense, but in their own sense and end up together. This way the plot is resolved, they end up together, but the country still has a tyrannical government. This book seems a lot more appropriate to real life, where everyone has their small victories but there are just some things over which you have no control. I would have enjoyed that book a lot as well. All that being said though, the Hunger Games is an enjoyable trilogy that doesn't require much thought but will prove to be highly entertaining as you do read it.